The Magic Ratio Of 5:1
Sunday, September 17, 2017
Not but whatever praise worked. It was to a greater extent than effective if praise was true together with related inwards existent fourth dimension to a specific event. It also had to survive sincere together with credible to remove maintain an impact.
I'm told, too, that a video analysis of the exercise sessions run past times John Wooden, arguably the greatest coach of all time, showed that 87% of his comments were positive reinforcement. Hmm, most a 5:1 ratio.
By the way--and peradventure (or peradventure not) a flake off our theme today--it was John Guttman inwards the 1990s who extended the query to married couples, showing that marriages were considerably to a greater extent than stable if at that spot were 5 times every bit many positive feelings together with interactions betwixt married adult man together with married adult woman every bit at that spot were negative. Guttman termed this the "magic ratio."
By contrast, I know of many leaders who intentionally run their companies every bit "low praise zones." When I was inwards the field government, ane of my colleagues did then for his agency. He berated people when they made errors (sometimes calling them belatedly at night) together with would seldom, if ever, plough over them praise for a project good done. Nonetheless, many of his managers adored him, were loyal to him, together with did every affair possible to brand him satisfied. The agency, past times the way, was successful inwards its mission inwards many respects.
It appeared to me that these managers were engaged inwards a human relationship designing equivalent to that of a codependent abused spouse. I've since seen it inwards other settings.
In the infirmary world, for example, I've seen a master copy of surgical operation who behaved inwards a similar fashion to my authorities colleague. Nary a sort give-and-take would come upwards out of his mouth. He ruled amongst fear, anger, together with disdain. And even then his underlings--whether care physicians or residents--would suck it upwards together with remove maintain it, almost every bit a badge of honor. They remained intensely loyal to him. The surgical operation department, past times the way, was quite good.
In the music world, I've seen a conductor of the same ilk. Sarcasm together with mean-spirited gossip were his weapons of choice. People who were the conductor's favorites on ane twenty-four hours would observe that, on another, they were inwards the domestic dog house. And yet, every bit above, the members of the ensemble were remarkably loyal. The music production of this group, past times the way, was excellent.
I'd similar to country that the 5:1 ratio is the way to become to arrive at a squad of engaged together with creative individuals best suited to send out the mission of an organization. It troubles me to scream upwards that the Commander Queeg approach I've but summarized mightiness operate every bit well. All I know is that it would brand me extremely uncomfortable to deport inwards such a way, together with then I've tended to attract managers who prefer my approach together with who remove maintain accomplished dandy things inwards places I've led.
If you lot are a leader inwards an organization, where arrive at you lot stand upwards on the spectrum of 5:1 versus 1:5?
--
* Kirkhart, Robert; Kirkhart, Evelyn (1972). "The Bruised Self: Mending inwards the Early Years". In Yamamoto, Kaoru. The Child together with His Image: Self Concept inwards the Early Years. New York: Houghton Mifflin. ISBN 0-395-12571-5.